Getting back together with your UFO

A couple of weekends ago, having just completed the pieced backing for a queen-size quilt and faced with the prospect of then basting said quilt, or maybe finishing marking and basting a twin-size quilt top, or perhaps marking and basting a throw-size quilt top (are you sensing a pattern here?), I took the easy way out: I pulled an even older UFO out of the closet and decided to work on it instead.

Back in 2004 or 2005, about a year or so after my husband and I had moved to Colorado, I decided to bust some stash and make a Centennial State-inspired delectable mountains quilt for our queen bed. I pulled a bunch of blue, green, red, orange, gold and ivory fabrics from my collection, with only a couple of tan or brown prints, and started to pair them up for the blocks.

mountains 1024x459 Getting back together with your UFO

No filter needed: the Rocky Mountains, November 2015, photo by Mary Kate Karr-Petras

My original intent was to make blocks that would gradate in value from the top of the quilt to the bottom, similar to how, when looking at the Rocky Mountains at sunset, the foothills are darkest while the highest peaks further away are much lighter, with the sky appearing golden at the very top. The concept isn’t a bad one, but it wasn’t an easy one to accomplish shopping only from my limited stash.

IMG 2578 225x300 Getting back together with your UFO

Half-square triangle units ready to be made into delectable mountains blocks

I used a quick-piecing method I learned from a book to make the blocks, very similar to the technique Lori Baker described in a different blog post. I finished 36 blocks, made pairs of half-square triangle units for approximately another 15 blocks, and still had a few more sets of squares cut and ready to be stitched for the bottom rows before I ran out of steam.

I’m trying to remember why I stopped when I did. It wasn’t simply a matter of being bored, although that was part of it. The design I had imagined (but didn’t sketch out in any way) wasn’t working as well in real life.

I asked an artist friend for her input, and she said she thought the greens were popping more than everything else and could maybe be tempered somehow. (I’ve since learned that green always pops out to her and is one of her least favorite colors in an arrangement, but I didn’t know that at the time.)

IMG 2626 Getting back together with your UFO

I also realized that despite my plan to represent the colors of the natural Colorado views I was seeing everywhere, I really didn’t have any brown neutrals except for a dark brown calico and an unbleached muslin with a music motif printed in gold metallic. Obviously I didn’t have much to choose from in my stash.

So I halted production until I could get ahold of some more browns, breaking my original self-imposed rule to only use what I already had for the blocks.

I had laid out my blocks, units and patches on a flat bed sheet that was functioning as a horizontal design wall and that could be rolled up and stored while maintaining my arrangement. See, if I still had everything laid out, then it wasn’t really a UFO, it was still a Work In Progress, right?


When my husband and I moved, that rolled-up sheet came with us and got put away. It made it through a number of reorganizations of my fabric storage over the years. Each time I thought to myself that I didn’t want to interfere with the work I had already done, so  I would find a spot for the rolled-and-now-also-folded-over portable design wall. And there it would sit.

In the meantime, as often happens with quilters, my tastes changed and I lost all interest in making a delectable mountains bed quilt.

I began to think that maybe I would cut my losses, make a large throw with what I’d already sewn and donate the quilt to a charity. In a recent fabric reorganization, I accepted the fact that I was not going to make the quilt I’d set out to make, so I unrolled the sheet, put the unsewn squares into a scrap bin, and stacked up the blocks and half-square triangle units and put them into a plastic bag.

I had officially broken up with my UFO. The relationship had been a dead shark for too long and it was time to let go of the promise it once held.

When I pulled the now-creased blocks and units out of my closet a couple of weeks ago as a way to keep sewing without having to baste first, I did so still thinking I was going to be making a donation quilt.

I arranged what I had on the bed in the approximate layout I originally planned. It was OK. But it still didn’t thrill me.

IMG 2583 Getting back together with your UFO

my original intended layout for the delectable mountains quilt

I decided to play with the arrangement. I tried a completely random layout, interspersing blocks of different values somewhat evenly.

IMG 2587 Getting back together with your UFO

random scrappy arrangement

I liked it. I liked how the scrappiness kept the eye moving, and how each block stood on its own and represented a different mountain view. The Rocky Mountains remind me of Monet’s haystacks — their size and shape never change (at least from my vantage point a few miles away) and yet they never look the same from one day to the next, even one hour to the next, because of the changing  seasons and light conditions. They’re a pretty magical thing to have in your backyard.

I tried a couple of other layouts, such as placing the lightest blocks in the center and gradating to the darker blocks at the edges.

IMG 2588 Getting back together with your UFO

gradating from light in the center to dark at the edges

I took a look at it from the opposite direction to see what secondary patterns, if any, might emerge.

IMG 2589 Getting back together with your UFO

gradating from light in the center to dark at the edges — opposite view

I was intrigued by the secondary patterns that are possible with a delectable mountains quilt. So I tried a layout of flipping the orientation of alternate rows to see what could happen.

IMG 2625 Getting back together with your UFO

alternating the orientation of alternate rows brings out a whole new pattern

Because I don’t know when I’ll make a delectable mountains quilt again, if ever, I decided to go with this approach, of alternating the direction of the blocks and arranging them to bring out secondary — and even tertiary — patterns.

IMG 2627 Getting back together with your UFO

interesting patterns emerge at block intersections

Even though it still may not be The Perfect Expression of a Delectable Mountains Quilt Design, I like its planned scrappy look well enough to keep it this way.

During the process of sewing and arranging over the course of about a week, I realized that I couldn’t donate this quilt. Too many of the fabrics I’d used now hold enormous sentimental value for me a decade (or even two) after I’d bought them.

For instance, that brown calico is one of the very first fabrics I bought when I made the decision to make a sampler quilt while working my way through Quilts! Quilts!! Quilts!!! by Diana McClun and Laura Nownes. I spent a loooonng time with that particular print.

Similarly, the navy blue-and-rust leaf print, ivory tone-on-tone leaf print, gold tone-on-tone floral, navy blue tone-on-tone floral, and a couple of the rust prints were all fabrics I used in a hand-appliqued and -quilted small throw. Again, I spent a lot of time with those fabrics, and the quilt they went into holds a special place in my heart now (I’ll write about it in more detail in a later blog post).

IMG 2628 Getting back together with your UFO

Some of the other fabrics, such as my perennial favorite map of Paris print from Moda’s Paris Flea Market collection and the music prints, I just like because of what they represent in my life.

So instead of donating this quilt, I decided to make it a large throw for our downstairs TV room/man cave. Without borders it measures 60″ x 67.5″, which is a nice size for a throw. Well, mathematically it should measure 60″ x 67.5″. In reality it’s … let’s just say it’s not 60″ x 67.5″.

One of the things that might happen when you reconnect with an ex, I mean, a UFO, is that mixed in with the nostalgia and affection for the good times you had there’s usually a reminder (or two, or more) of why you broke up in the first place.

Deciding to finish this quilt meant deciding to accept the choices Mary Kate of 11 years ago made and not try to fix them. For instance, for some reason I thought it was important to match thread colors to my fabrics whenever possible, regardless of weight, quality or fiber content. Which means I have a good amount of mid-quality cotton-poly thread in this quilt.

Also, I apparently didn’t understand thread tension very well, or maybe it was my pressing, because there are a number of seams that look like this.

IMG 2579 Getting back together with your UFO

The diagonal seam was stitched 11 years ago; the vertical seam was stitched last week.

Granted, 1) that seam was stitched on the bias, 2) the green check fabric is yarn-dyed and of a looser weave than the quilting cottons, and 3) I did not understand how helpful starch is back then, but still. That is not great.

As I said, I decided not to reprimand myself for how I sewed 11 years ago. I just decided to meet myself in the middle as it were and do the best job possible.

I didn’t use any starch, but I pressed and re-pressed the blocks so the seams would interlock when put together in rows; I used only 50-weight, neutral cotton threads; and instead of focusing on aligning raw edges, I focused on making my seams line up as much as possible. With so many seam intersections, it meant I had to take my time stitching the rows together, but the end result is worth it.

All that’s left now is to add some narrow borders — in a lovely dark brown pulled from my current stash — for stability, and then this quilt top will again become a UFO. With the weather warming up we won’t need it for the man cave anytime soon, and I really do want to get around to quilting the tops mentioned earlier. Come the fall, though, I know this project will be waiting for me and I’ll enjoy the reunion.

Because with exes and UFOs, even if the romance will never be there again, after all these years it’s nice to know you can still be friends.


QNS1501 Getting back together with your UFO

QN Select: Editors’ Choice Kit

As I mentioned above, I found Quilts! Quilts!! Quilts!!! by Diana McClun and Laura Nownes to be an invaluable resource when I was a beginning quilter, and I still value having it in my personal library. We included the Third Edition in our QN Select: Editors’ Choice Kit along with other basics we know will make your sewing life easier, such as high-quality neutral cotton threads from Aurifil, glass-head pins, and a 12.5″ square ruler.

I would have saved a lot of time and energy with my delectable mountains blocks 11 years ago if I wasn’t trying to match thread colors and then fighting with tension issues because of using different weights and fibers. Had I known to just stick with neutral 50-weight cotton threads for my piecing, I probably would have gotten a lot further. I also know that if I’d had a 12.5″ square ruler back then, cutting my units would have gone faster and easier. Did I get by without those things? Yes. Would my work have been better (and a lot less frustrating) if I’d had them? Absolutely.

That’s why we included what we did in our Editors’ Choice Kit. Our collective experience has shown us what we consider to be the quilting basics that make sewing easier, more technically accurate and much more satisfying, and we know you’ll think so too. Click here to learn more about the QN Select: Editors’ Choice Kit, available from Quilt and Sew Shop.

As always, to find out about Quilters Newsletter’s giveaways, quilting news, tips, techniques and more, visit us on Facebook,  Twitter,  Google+,  Pinterest,  Instagram,  YouTube, and our website. Plus, see  Web Seminars on and classes, courses and workshops on  Craft and

About Mary Kate Karr-Petras

Mary Kate is an associate editor at Quilters Newsletter. If you ask her what type of quilter she considers herself, she'll answer, "Slow." Favorite techniques include hand quilting, both traditional and big stitch, but she also loves her walking foot and keeps meaning to get better acquainted with her open-toe embroidery foot.
This entry was posted in Mary Kate Karr-Petras and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Getting back together with your UFO

  1. Christine Keay says:

    Last weekend I should have pieced backing for a queen size quilt and got on with wadding, backing and tacking. I chose to finish a foundation pieced flip and sew strippy which was supposed to go to a charity as I didn’t think I liked it. It was a pig to hand quilt as it had 4 layers. It had been an ongoing project for about 6 years.Now I can’t part with it, it contains scrap strips from all the quilts made for my kids and friends over the last 30 years. It even has a tiny scrap from my youngest son’s baby nest( he’s 36!). This weekend I have to get cracking on the queen size, a 1 year late wedding present for my niece. But I feel good that the UFO strippy is finally finished.

  2. Mary Kate, this post really resonated with me. Quilts! Quilts!! Quilts!!! was the book I used when I made MY first quilt, too! I made the Roman Square for my 2-year-old son (he’s 15 now) and I remember how I really wanted to buy those beautiful batiks that reminded me of watercolors but the “helpful” salesNazis at the quilt shop told me they were not suitable for beginners for some reason. They steered me towards more traditional fabrics, browns… Not at all what I quilt with today. But whenever I can sneak a scrap from any of those fabrics into a quilt today, it is REALLY, REALLY SPECIAL!!

    Best of wishes with your mountain quilt. I do like the new arrangement, and it’s a wonderful opportunity for you to appreciate how far your skills have come.

  3. LeslieSusan says:

    Rebecca Grace, as a former employee of a quilt shop myself, I am very sorry you ran into that. What indeed were those salesNazis thinking? Batiks are wonderful to work with.
    I like to prewash them and use some kind of color retaining solution to eliminate any possibility of color running from darks to lights in future projects. I can tell you I would NEVER have dreamed of stifling your’s or anyone’s dreams or creativity in that way.
    This was indeed a very good post. I too am struggling with a small stack of UFO/WIP’s myself. It is more I dread giving them away than it is boredom though to be honest.

  4. robin schmidt says:

    I want to second your thoughts about QUILTS! QUILTS! QUILTS! It was what turned me into a quilter back in the early 80′s. I started making a couple of the quilts from the book and was immediately hooked. The book gave me all the information I needed (well, with an occasional trip to a local quilt store to get an occasional question clarified — as well as all the fabric I could ever want, of course!). It never occurred to me that I could not make pretty much whatever was in the book because the directions were so very clear. I still have it and, I will admit, from time to time I open it up. To this day their views are refreshing and clear. I have recommended it to just about every new (or even not so new) quilter as a primary tool. I haven’t even seen the updated editions, though I assume they are as wonderful as the first edition is.

  5. Pingback: The quilt I made for my parents | Inside Quilters Newsletter

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>